This CIP proposes that the Mission Guild be dissolved (sunset) effective July 1, 2022. Why would I want to dissolve something that I love being a part of and I helped create? Glad you asked.
Background
The Bundled Guild proposal established Mission Guild made up of 13 core members and city council members. We created this Guild for the purpose of developing and implementing the “mission” of CityDAO. We are in the process of finalizing the mission which we are attempting to encapsulate in a one-page document led by @Da3vid. Once this is finalized the purpose of the Mission Guild will have been fulfilled. The implementation of this mission should now be handed off to all CityDAO NFT holders (“Citizens”).
Our Mission Guild has discussed whether to increase our authority and duties in private threads (which is in itself beyond our authority and could create legal issues—a discussion beyond the scope of this CIP). This CIP opens up the discussion for our community as a whole to decide.
One argument for maintaining the Mission Guild is that the 13 Guild members are benevolent and have the best intentions for CityDAO, so they should be entrusted with supervisory and veto authority to guide CityDAO forward. I disagree with this argument because it assumes that we cannot trust our Citizens with making decisions that benefit our community. Every Citizen has bought their NFT with their hard-earned money by purchasing their NFT, which gives us all, collectively, the right to shape the future of CityDAO–for better or for worse.
Another argument in favor of the Mission Guild is that it can guard against undue influence by a “whale” that has too many votes. This is addressed by implementing quadratic voting, proof of humanity and one-person-one-vote that we are in the process of putting up on snapshot.
I have nothing but love, respect and admiration for our core team and our city council. I trust each one of them be benevolent and want what is best for our community, but that is not what a DAO is meant to do. A DAO is meant to be decentralized and allow the collective consciousness to shape our future. A DAO is also meant to be autonomous—a sovereign, self-governed community. The Mission Guild creates unnecessary centralization in the 13 of us who have supplanted ourselves as benevolent dictators of CityDAO. As Citizens we have bought our Freedom, sovereignty and decentralization through approval of CIP 35 and CIP 40, which generously compensates the core team and council members for our services up to now—we no longer have or need overlords to decide on our behalf.
It is time to remove the training wheels and have our community to take the reigns of CityDAO. Our Charter already has mechanisms that will allow any Citizen to create and repeal any CIP. The Charter also gives any Citizen the power to initiate the removal of any facilitator or co-facilitator that is not serving the will of our community.
More importantly, our Charter provides a mechanism for the creation and implementation of Guilds, Guild facilitators and co-facilitators that are meant to be servants and facilitate the will of our community. Each member of the Mission Guild is already a facilitator or contributor of our other current Guilds. We are paying our facilitators salaries equivalent to $120,000 per year to serve the Citizens, which they are doing a great job at. The Operations Guild led by @lyons and @fugyeah, for example, is doing a great job with coordinating all the Guilds and providing for smooth operations of our community.
The promise of Web3 and DAOs is to give equal power, ownership and governance to ALL the people. Allowing the Mission Guild to remain will harbor the centralization and bureaucracy that belongs to the cities of old.
Approving this CIP will dissolve the Mission Guild effective July 1, 2022. This CIP will also make Facilitators responsible for the duties that were imputed to the Mission Guild in the Charter.
If you approve this CIP to go to snapshot, click like (the heart emoji). Once it reaches 20 likes it will go to snapshot.